Barbecue Grill Buying Guide: (Beginner to Pitmaster)

Grilling is not just a way of cooking; it’s a way of life for many. But with so many grill options available, it can be overwhelming for beginners to choose the right one. Fear not, because this barbecue grill buying guide is here to help you navigate the world of grills.

Barbecue Grill Buying Guide

Barbecue Grill Buying Guide

We’ll explore the four main types of grills, starting from the basics and working our way up to the ultimate grilling experience.

Read More: The 10 Best Stove Top Grill

Gas Grill: The Gateway Grill

Gas Grill

Convenience at Your Fingertips

The gas grill is the perfect starting point for any aspiring grill master. It’s incredibly convenient, allowing you to dial in the temperature with a simple knob turn. You can be ready to cook in as little as 10-15 minutes, and maintenance is minimal. The consistent results of a gas grill make it ideal for cooking for a large crowd, ensuring your food is always cooked to perfection.


Some may argue that gas grills lack the smoky flavor of other grilling methods, but that’s a misconception. As the juices and fats from your food drip onto the diffuser bars, they vaporize and infuse your meat with a unique flavor that you can’t achieve with an indoor skillet or oven.

Choosing the Right Gas Grill

When shopping for a gas grill, consider these two key factors:

  • Number of Burners: Aim for at least three burners. This allows for indirect cooking, which is essential for roasted chicken items. It prevents burning and ensures even cooking.
  • Lid Quality: A heavier lid indicates better heat retention and durability. Give it a gentle push to check for stability; a wobbly grill may not last long.

Who Should Buy a Gas Grill?

Gas grills are perfect for apartment dwellers, those facing burn bans, busy individuals looking for quick weeknight meals, and beginners learning grilling basics.

Pellet Grill: The Smoker’s Dream

Pellet Grill

Smoke, Set, and Forget

Pellet grills use compressed wood sawdust pellets for both heat and flavor. They are a favorite among those who love smoked food without the hassle of traditional smoking methods. Pellet grills offer incredible convenience, thanks to electronic controllers that allow you to set the temperature and walk away until your food is ready.

Portability and Range

While pellet grills were once primarily for backyards, manufacturers have created portable options for tailgating and on-the-go grilling. Some models even run on battery backups for added flexibility. Prices for pellet grills typically range from $400 to $1,500, with advanced features available at higher price points.

Must-Have Features

Consider these features when selecting a pellet grill:

  • PID Controller: For precise temperature control and consistency.
  • Wi-Fi: Allows remote control and monitoring via a mobile app.
  • Searing Options: Some models have side burners for searing, while others offer a blast door for direct access to the fire.

When to Choose a Pellet Grill

If you love smoked foods without the effort, value convenience, and don’t mind the lighter smoke flavor at higher temperatures, a pellet grill is a great choice.

Charcoal Grill: Total Control

Charcoal Grill

The Art of Charcoal Grilling

Charcoal grills offer complete control over your grilling experience. While they may seem daunting at first, they become second nature with practice. You control the temperature by adjusting airflow through vents, offering various cooking possibilities.

Versatile and Affordable

Charcoal grills are incredibly versatile, allowing you to smoke cheese at low temperatures or sear a steak at high heat. They offer excellent value, with prices ranging from $150 to $300 for new models. You can often find quality used grills on the secondhand market.

Key Considerations

When shopping for a charcoal grill, keep these factors in mind:

  • Grill Grate Thickness: Thicker grates tend to be more durable.
  • Vent Handles: Look for cool-touch handles on vents to avoid burns.
  • Ash Collection System: Evaluate the efficiency of the ash collection system.

For the Ultimate Control Freaks

Charcoal grills are for those who want precise control over every aspect of their grilling experience. They’re perfect for anyone willing to try to learn the art of grilling.

Offset Smoker: The Pitmaster’s Choice

Offset Smoker

A Live Fire Experience

Offset smokers are the choice of barbecue pitmasters. They use an all-wood fire for cooking, creating unparalleled smoke flavor. Professionals commonly use these smokers, but smaller, backyard-friendly versions are available.

A Pricey Pursuit

Offset smokers can be expensive, with prices starting at a minimum of $1,000 and going up significantly for larger models. Due to their cost and complexity, they are not recommended as a first grill.

The Ultimate Respect

Owning an offset smoker earns fellow grill enthusiasts’ respect and admiration. It’s a commitment to the art of barbecue.


So, which grill is right for you? Consider your needs, budget, and level of grilling enthusiasm. Gas grills offer convenience and ease for beginners. Pellet grills provide smoky flavor with minimal effort. Charcoal grills grant complete control over your cooking. Offset smokers are the pinnacle of barbecue perfection but are cheaper.

Whether you’re a novice looking to start your grilling journey or a seasoned pitmaster seeking the ultimate flavor, there’s a grill out there for you.